L-carnitine improves : Part 2
Materials and methods
Experimental animals, location and design
This trial was carried out at the Iran Ostrich Research Company (Tehran) using 60 female
and 30 male breeders, forming 15 units (breeder pens) consisting of four females and two
males. At the beginning of the trial, all breeders were 5-year old South African black neck
ostriches. They were selected from ostriches that had a steady production rate during the
previous two breeding seasons. The trial was conducted over a 7-month period, from the
beginning of March to the end of September 2005.
Experimental treatments
Fifteen experimental units were distributed randomly in three equal treatment groups with
five replicates. The treatments were: L1, control group (basal diet); L2, control group + 250
mg L-carnitine per kg feed; and L3, control group + 500 mg L-carnitine per kg feed. The
L-carnitine was supplied as a white powder with 20% purity (Lohmann Co., Cuxhaven,
Germany).
Basal diet fed to ostriches
Composition and proximate analyses of the basal diet are indicated in Table 1. Each ostrich
breeder received 2.3 kg of diet once a day between 0900 and 1000 hours.
Measurements
Mating occurred naturally and the eggs were collected each day at sunset. Data recorded
were: the number of eggs laid, egg weight and the number of the experimental units. The
fresh eggs were then sorted and the defective eggs were removed. Defective eggs,
including deformed eggs, chalky eggs, cracked eggs and eggs without calcite shell
membranes were not incubated.
Eggs production, egg weight and the number of defective eggshells were recorded and
converted to percentages: (i) egg production percentage (EPP, North and Bell 1990) in each
experimental group was calculated by dividing the number of eggs laid by the number of
ostrich days in a month multiplied by 100; (ii) average weight of the eggs was calculated by
dividing the total egg weight by the total number of produced eggs in each month for the
experimental unit; and (iii) defective eggshell percentage (DEP) in each experimental
group was calculated by dividing the number of defective eggshells by the total number of
eggs produced in a month. Egg production percentage, egg weight (g) and DEP were
statistically analysed during the whole period and monthly.
Statistical analysis
The statistical analysis model used was:
Yij = μ – ti – εijk
where Yi,j is any observation for which X1= i (i and j denote the level of the factor and the
replication within the level of the factor, respectively); μ is the general location parameter;
Ti is the effect of having treatment level i; and εijk is random error. The statistical analysis
of data was performed using the SAS (SAS Institute 1986) program based on ANOVA.
Significant differences between means were determined using Duncan’s multiple range test
(Duncan 1955).
Results
The effects of L-carnitine on egg production are presented in Table 2. The inclusion of
L-carnitine in the diet of ostrich breeders significantly (P < 0.05) increased egg production
with the highest difference occurring between treatments L1 and L3. There was no
significant difference between the averages of egg production in treatment L2 with
treatments L1 and L3. There was no significant difference in egg weights between the
different treatments for the duration of the trial period (Table 2).
The effect of L-carnitine on the means of defective eggshell for the different treatments is
shown in Table 2; however, there was no significant difference between the different
treatments for the trial period.
Discussion
The influence of dietary L-carnitine supplementation on egg production and fertility of
ostriches was previously investigated by Davis et al. (1997). In their report, the supplement
was given to the treatment group in drinking water at a rate of 1 mL/bird.day. Results from
that study showed that the treated
Table 1. Composition and proximate analyses of the basal diet of the ostrich (Aganga et al. 2003)
Components of diet Amount in diet (%)
Yellow maize 22.63
Alfalfa hay 23.14
Soybean oilcake meal 13.6
Wheat bran 18
Sunflower oilcake meal 12.32
Vegetable oil 1.33
Salt 0.43
Dicalcium phosphate 1.37
Limestone 5.93
DL-methionine 0.25
Vitamin and mineral premix 1
Calculated nutrient content
TME(Kcal/kg)A 2600
n Crude protein (%) 16
Crude fibre (%) 12.72
Calcium (%) 3
Available phosphorus (%) 0.5
Sodium (%) 0.22
Lysine (%) 0.7
Methionine + cysteine (%) 0.5
ATME, true metabolisable energy corrected for nitrogen retention.